Article

ABOUT THAT POSSIBLE NEW HOTEL IN PATCHOGUE VILLAGE

January 16, 2025

Tonight, the Patchogue Village Board of Trustees is meeting on a needed zoning change that if approved will help speed the construction of a new hotel in Patchogue Village on the Patchogue river. Pictured today is a rendering of the proposed Tempo hotel under the Hilton hotel banner. (photo credit: Newsday)

Readers might ask what any of this has to do with Cherry Grove and FI Pines. The answer is, right now not much, but in a few years maybe a lot.

Part of this proposed hotel application includes a plan to dredge for a new marina on the Patchogue River near the hotel. Only a stone’s throw away actually. Once that is done, and that looks to be about 3 years from now after construction is finished, a very interesting option might take shape. And that option would be a new direct water taxi link from Patchogue Village to FI Pines and Cherry Grove.

For those traveling from the west taking the train to Patchogue would add about 10 minutes to the train trip. But once at the Patchogue train station, unlike today, it would be a short walk to the hotel and the marina there to link up with a water taxi. No shuttle service would be needed from the Sayville train station to the ferry connection in Sayville. The train trip would be longer but overall travel time to FI might turn out to be shorter and less complicated.

The waiting area would include the amenities of the nearby hotel.

Also train service from Patchogue is actually superior to that that can be found in Sayville. For example, on weekends there are several express trains to NYC that would take a rider from Patchogue to the Jamaica train station with no stops in between.

The train station in Patchogue too is now undergoing a major renovation and included in that is new outside  lighting  making it a safer wait area for trains in either direction.

For those traveling from the east the benefit would be a shorter route to a water taxi with all the benefits previously detailed.

This idea is already getting mentioned at public meetings in Patchogue Village. H20 water limo that already provides water taxi service between FI Pines and Cherry Grove and cross bay trips too does so from a location in Blue Pt. A new Patchogue Village pick up and drop off site could prove very attractive to it to use. It already has a license to sail on the Patchogue river and does so now from time to time promoting Patchogue riverfront events.

It should also be mentioned that the availability of hotel rooms in Patchogue Village, with good connections to FI, also raises the possibility of some visitors finding housing for day trips too that could actually reach far into the night hours depending on what water taxi service might occur in the future from the marina near the hotel.

If no water taxi service ever occurs, if just the hotel opens up that that would still be a benefit by helping with today’s housing crunch for visitors to Cherry Grove and FI Pines. Rail service from

Patchogue Village is frequent, fast, and low cost in either direction to the Sayville train station.

None of this is happening now. And it’s far from being a done deal. The devil is always in the details. But it’s an evolving story worth keep an eye on because of its potential impacts for a lot of people.


The views and opinions expressed in this blog post are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect the views or positions of any entities they represent or the owners of the Boys of Fire Island site.

share this

Related Articles

Related Articles

What Makes a Stay Feel Seamless?

By Julian Morales • March 30, 2026
Most groups booking a Fire Island Pines vacation rental spend the most time on the wrong question. They compare photos. They read amenity lists. They check the number of bedrooms against the number of people. What they rarely think to ask is whether the home they are considering will actually work for the specific way their group moves through a week together. That gap, between a listing that looks right and a stay that delivers, is where most rental weeks either hold together or quietly fall apart. It has nothing to do with how much you spend or how close to the water you are. It comes down to a handful of things that almost no listing page names. BēKin has been inside these homes. Here is what to look for. What the Home Itself Has to Deliver A listing photographs a mood. Afternoon light through floor-to-ceiling windows. A deck that seems to extend forever. A kitchen that looks built for cooking. What it cannot photograph is how the home actually holds six people across seven days. The gap between a home that looks right and one that functions right is almost entirely in the details most listing descriptions skip. Bed configuration relative to group size. Whether the kitchen is set up for more than one person to move through at the same time. How the outdoor space relates to the indoor one, and whether it creates a real third zone or just a backdrop. How the bedrooms sit relative to the main living area, because a beautiful open-plan space right off the bedroom corridor means early risers and late sleepers are negotiating from the first morning. The homes that get this right have been thought through, not just photographed.

What Makes a Pines Home Feel Right

By Julian Morales • March 13, 2026
Last summer, a group of eight friends rented an oceanfront home in the Pines. Four bedrooms, a wraparound deck, unobstructed water views. By day three, two couples had retreated to their rooms by nine at night. The other four were still going at two in the morning. Not because anyone had a bad week. Because the home had one living space with the bedrooms right off it, and nowhere to be that wasn't in someone else's way. The house looked beautiful. For that group, it was the wrong home.  Knowing how to choose a Fire Island Pines rental isn't just about finding something you love on a listing page. It's about understanding what a home will feel like to live in, together, for seven days. Those are two different questions, and they have two different answers.

Oceanfront, Harbor-Side, or Tucked Away?

By Julian Morales • March 2, 2026
Every group has this conversation at some point. Someone says oceanfront and it sounds right, the way it always sounds right. Someone else mentions the harbor is where everything happens. A third person suggests mid-island as a compromise. Nobody commits, and the group spends another two weeks in the chat without a booking.  Most of the disagreement is not about preference. It is about not knowing what each choice actually means for how the week plays out. Oceanfront sounds obvious until you understand what you are giving up. Harbor-side sounds social until you realize it is something more specific than that. Mid-island sounds safe until you understand when it works and when it does not. This is our take on all three. Not a tour. A recommendation.
ALL ARTICLES